Though I don't wear lipstick a ton, I do try to wear liner with anything that's not more sheer/balmy. Often I opt for a clear liner, simply because it's easy...but since last Fall I've found a closely matching liner actually seems to work better (it's easier to create my lip shape with a liner and then fill in vs. using a clear liner and then using the lipstick bullet to shape). Here are the non-clear lip liners that are currently in my stash...

***All products purchased by me. Non-affiliate links. This is not a sponsored post.***

Pretty Charlotte Tilbury heavy here, but what can I say...she makes a great product!!

Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat in Berry Naughty (for my darker berry colors), Bad Romance (for my more purple-y vamps), Pillowtalk (this one is a tad more flattering than Iconic Nude so I've actually purged that one). 

NARS Velvet Lip Liner in El Agua - This is a little too cool toned for most of my lipsticks, so I usually wear it with gloss or Chanel RCS in Intime (I'm still working on finishing it!). It's a little more creamy than the Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheats, but it also doesn't seem to last quite as long. 

Here are swatches! 

Do you have any of these? What lip pencils do you depend on?